Frequently asked questions
Don’t see yours? Call us at (786) 876-9600.

Booking
How do we book?
Pick a trip and a date and book it right here with a 25% deposit; the rest is due on the day. You can always call or text Captain Johnny at (786) 876-9600 first.
How much does a fishing charter in Marathon cost?
A half day is $795 on Papa Two or $850 on Papa Papa, for the whole boat. A three-hour quick trip is $695, six hours from $995, a full day $1,295, and the big game offshore trip $1,795.
Is the price per person?
No. Every trip is private and priced for the boat, up to 6 guests.
What if the weather's bad?
Captain Johnny makes the call based on the actual conditions. When the ocean side is rough he can often fish the calmer water of Florida Bay and the Seven Mile Bridge instead. If it isn't safe to go out, he'll move your trip or cancel it, and you won't lose your deposit.
What's your cancellation policy?
Free cancellation with at least 48 hours' notice.
How much should we tip?
A tip of 15 to 20% of the trip for your mate is customary. The mate works for tips, so it's appreciated.
Is there a veteran discount?
Yes. Captain Johnny is a Marine Corps veteran, and veterans get 10% off every trip. Mention it when you call or book.
The fishing
What's the best time of year to fish in Marathon?
Any time. Marathon fishes all year; what changes is what bites. Winter brings a big reef bite for yellowtail and mutton snapper, mackerel and kingfish, with sailfish and wahoo offshore. Mahi run from April through October, biggest in May. Grouper can be kept from May through December.
What fish can we catch in Marathon?
On the reef and the wrecks, yellowtail, mangrove and mutton snapper, grouper, amberjack, mackerel, barracuda and sharks. Offshore, mahi, blackfin tuna, wahoo and sailfish, with marlin and swordfish on the long days. Tell Captain Johnny what you're after and he'll point you to the right trip.
When is mahi season in Marathon?
April through October, with the big bulls in May. Book the run and gun, the full offshore day or the big game trip, and call Captain Johnny first if mahi are the reason you're coming; he'll tell you how far out they are.
When is grouper season?
Grouper can be kept from May 1 through December. From January 1 to May 1 they're closed, so any grouper you catch goes back. Snapper are open all year.
How far offshore do you go?
It depends on the trip and the bite. The reef is a short run from the marina, under the Seven Mile Bridge. Offshore trips run past the reef to the Humps, the Ups and Downs and the Ledge, and in summer the mahi can be 20 miles out or more. Captain Johnny goes where the fish are, not farther.
Do we need fishing experience?
No. Plenty of guests have never held a rod. The crew rigs the tackle, baits the hooks and shows you what to do when a fish is on.
The day
Do we need a fishing license?
No. The boats carry the state and federal fishing permits, so nobody needs a separate license.
What's included?
Your captain and mate, rods, reels, tackle, live bait and licenses, and the crew cleans your catch at the end of the trip.
Can we bring kids?
Yes. Families are most of the bookings, and the half day and the quick trip stay close to shore, which suits kids best.
Can we keep our fish?
Yes, within the season and size limits. The crew cleans your keepers, and Keys Fisheries and Lazy Days will cook them for you.
What should we bring?
Your own food and drinks (cans and plastic only, no glass), sunscreen, a hat and sunglasses. If you get seasick, Captain Johnny swears by ginger, even ginger snaps.
Where do we meet?
At Keys Fisheries Marina, 3502 Gulfview Ave, Marathon, FL 33050. Arrive 30 minutes before your trip. Guests at Marlin Bay and Banana Bay can ask about a pickup at the resort's dock.
Is there a bathroom on board?
Yes, Papa Papa has a toilet.

Still wondering?
Not sure which trip or boat fits your group? Call or text Captain Johnny before you book.