Marathon sits in the middle of the Florida Keys, with Florida Bay and the Gulf on one side and the Atlantic reef line and deep blue water on the other. From Keys Fisheries Marina, Captain Johnny can fish the bay and the Seven Mile Bridge, the reef and the wrecks, or run offshore to the Marathon Humps, the Ups and Downs and the Ledge. The boats carry the state and federal fishing permits, so nobody needs a license.
The fishing runs all year. What changes with the seasons is what bites.
What’s biting by season
Winter: December to February
Cooler water brings a big bite on the reef. Captain Johnny’s January reports are yellowtail and mutton snapper, cero mackerel and kingfish. Offshore, the cooler months are the time for sailfish, wahoo and cobia.
When the wind keeps the boats off the ocean, Florida Bay still fishes. On one rough February morning a family from Michigan booked a half day in the bay for Spanish mackerel and, in his words, just got tired of catching.
Grouper are closed to keeping from January 1 until May 1, so a grouper you catch in those months goes back.
Spring: March to May
Mahi start showing offshore in April, and May is the month for the big bull mahi. Sailfish and wahoo can still be around early in the spring, and amberjack and mutton snapper come into their season. Grouper open again on May 1.
Spring can blow. In 2015 the wind ran 15 to 20 knots from the south-southeast for two weeks of May, and Captain Johnny kept the boats in on the days the seas hit five to seven feet. He makes the call on the day.
Summer: June to August
Summer is mahi season. The crew runs offshore and looks for birds working a weed line and floating debris, where the mahi hold. How far out they are changes week to week; in July 2015 they were 20 to 25 miles out. Blackfin tuna and wahoo are out there too, and marlin are in season.
On the reef, July is when the snapper spawn, and they feed hard around it. Yellowtail, mangrove and mutton snapper all bite well through the summer.
Fall: September to November
Mahi can hang on into October. As the water cools, wahoo, sailfish, cobia and the mackerels move back in, and grouper season stays open through December, so fall is a good time to fill the cooler on the reef and the wrecks.
Yellowtail and mangrove snapper, sharks and blackfin tuna are around all year.
Where Captain Johnny fishes
Florida Bay and the Seven Mile Bridge
The sheltered Gulf-side water behind Marathon, and the pilings of the Seven Mile Bridge. Mangrove snapper, Spanish mackerel, grouper, jacks, barracuda, sharks and the odd cobia. It’s where the quick trip goes, and where Captain Johnny takes a half day when the ocean side is too rough to enjoy.
The reef
Out of the marina, the boats run under the Seven Mile Bridge and south to the Marathon reef line. This is yellowtail country, with mutton snapper, grouper, mackerel, barracuda and sharks on the same reefs. Most half days fish here.
The wrecks
Wrecks hold bait, and bait holds bigger fish: amberjack, grouper and big snapper. A wreck stop fits in a half day, and a three-quarter or full day can work several.
Offshore: the Humps, the Ups and Downs and the Ledge
Past the reef the water turns deep and blue. The Marathon Humps and the Ups and Downs are underwater rises that change the current and bunch up the bait; the Ledge is the edge of deeper water beyond them. This is where Captain Johnny hunts mahi, blackfin tuna, wahoo and sailfish, with marlin and swordfish possible on the long days. His biggest fish is a 400-pound striped marlin.
Which trip to book
- Young kids and first-timers: the Quick Trip (3 hours from 7am) or the Half Day (4 hours, morning or afternoon) on the reef and in the bay.
- Snapper and grouper for dinner: the Half Day, or six hours on the reef and the wrecks on the Three Quarter Day.
- Mahi: the offshore run and gun on the Three Quarter Day, or the Full Day offshore on Papa Papa, from April through October.
- Big fish: the Big Game Offshore Adventure, 9 to 10 hours at the Humps and the Ledge.
Every trip is private and priced for the boat, up to 6 guests. Not sure what fits? Call or text Captain Johnny at (786) 876-9600 and he’ll tell you what’s been biting.
After the trip
The crew cleans your keepers at the dock. Take them to Keys Fisheries or Lazy Days and they’ll cook them for you.

