When the water cools off in the Keys, the reef in front of Marathon wakes up. Captain Johnny’s report from the first weekend of January said it plainly: cooler temps mean a big bite on the reef. That day it was yellowtail and mutton snapper, with cero mackerel and kingfish mixed in.
The rest of the winter kept that pace.
January
Two anglers from Tennessee fished a morning half day in early January and said they caught fish from the moment they got there until it was time to leave. They had their limit before the time was up. Later in the month a group of three on the three-hour trip called it a great day on the water with great fishing.
February
In mid-February two anglers took the morning half day. It was a nice ride out to the Atlantic, and within minutes they were on fish. It didn’t take long to fill their yellowtail limits, and they added mackerel and a rainbow runner on top.
What winter fishing off Marathon looks like
- The reef is the place. Yellowtail and mutton snapper are the main event, with cero mackerel and kingfish around.
- Grouper go back. Grouper are closed to keeping from January 1 until May 1, so the ones you catch in winter are released.
- Wind decides the day. Winter fronts can blow the ocean side out. On those days Florida Bay still fishes, and Captain Johnny makes the call on the morning.
The Half Day and the Quick Trip both fish the reef in winter. The crew cleans your keepers at the dock, and Keys Fisheries will cook them for you. For more on the seasons, see the Marathon fishing guide.

